वरेण्य उवाच । संन्यस्तिश्चैव योगश्च कर्मणां वर्ण्यते त्वया । उभयोर्निश्चितं त्वेकं श्रेयो यद्वद मे प्रभो ॥४-१॥
vareṇya uvāca | saṃnyastiścaiva yogaśca karmaṇāṃ varṇyate tvayā | ubhayorniścitaṃ tvekaṃ śreyo yadvada me prabho ||4-1||
Both renunciation of actions and the yoga of action are described by you. Tell me, O lord, which one of the two is definitely better.
Modern Reflection
A talented young classical musician in Kolkata, midway through conservatory training, asks her own guru a version of this exact question: should she pursue the ascetic path of a soloist who withdraws from ensemble work to perfect a single voice, or the collaborative path of constant ensemble performance that never lets any one skill fully mature in isolation, since both paths are held up as valid within her own tradition and she cannot tell which one is actually meant for her. Her guru's eventual answer, that the two are not really opposites but two names for the same disciplined attention applied differently, mirrors almost exactly the answer this chapter is about to give Vareṇya. Neither path is presented as wrong in her tradition; the question she brings her guru is exactly Vareṇya's question, which one is definitely better for her specifically.